Turns out there can be trouble in paradise! Love stories in Hollywood often seem like fairytales, but even our favorite stars grapple with the complexities of relationships, especially when it comes to marriage proposals. Let’s dive into some surprising twists in the romantic narratives of well-known personalities. These celebrity marriage proposal rejections will leave you jaw-dropped.
1. Reese Witherspoon and Jake Gyllenhaal
After her divorce from Ryan Phillippe, Reese Witherspoon reportedly turned down a proposal from Jake Gyllenhaal. Witherspoon, expressing uncertainty about marriage, emphasized the significance of family in her life.
Witherspoon had said in an interview for People, “Obviously, I’m not far enough out of being married to think about doing it again. You sort of reconstitute your family. You find a family with people who come into your life for a reason.”
“Family is all we have in life, but I don’t know how I feel about marriage,” she contemplated at that time.
2. Jennifer Lopez and Casper Smart
Despite being married three times, Jennifer Lopez faced persistent proposals from Casper Smart in 2015, reportedly turning him down at least five times. Frustrated with the repeated attempts, Lopez firmly asked Smart to stop proposing, marking the end of their romantic journey.
3. Kate Upton and Justin Verlander
Before their eventual 2017 wedding, Kate Upton reportedly declined Justin Verlander’s 2015 proposal. Upton, confident in her relationship, believed she had time before taking on the role of a wife. Her prediction proved right, as they happily tied the knot two years later. A source told OK!, “She feels like she has years to be a wife. She’s so confident in her relationship that she knows Justin will wait.”
4. Marilyn Monroe and Frank Sinatra
Guess who made the list of celebrity marriage proposal rejections! Even iconic stars like Marilyn Monroe experienced unexpected turns in their love lives. Frank Sinatra proposed to Monroe, but she declined, revealing that even glamourous figures face uncertain paths in matters of the heart. In the biography ‘Sinatra: The Chairman,’ Jilly Rizzo, Sinatra’s closest aide, told James Kaplan, “Frank wanted to marry the broad. He asked her, and she said no.”
5. Nicole Scherzinger and Lewis Hamilton
Former power couple Nicole Scherzinger and Lewis Hamilton went through ups and downs. After their 2013 split, Hamilton proposed to Scherzinger in an attempt to reconcile, but she turned down the proposal, marking the final end of their romance.
6. Kylie Jenner and Travis Scott
In 2018, Kylie Jenner reportedly declined Travis Scott’s spontaneous marriage proposal during a romantic getaway. Preferring to savor each stage of their relationship, Jenner took advice from her sister Khloe Kardashian to delay wedding plans. Despite their 2022 split, the couple shares two children.
A source told Hollywood Life, “When Kylie and Travis were on their trip he spontaneously asked her to marry him, but she turned him down, for now.” The insider also mentioned that Khloe Kardashian has been a big source of guidance for her, encouraging her to take her time and be patient when it comes to the whole marriage thing.
7. Britney Spears and Jason Trawick
Nowadays celebrity marriage proposal rejections from men are becoming more of a norm. This is true for pop sensation Britney Spears. She faced relationship drama with Jason Trawick. Trawick initially turned down Spears’ proposal, stating that he “takes marriage very seriously.” The engagement didn’t stand the test of time, leading to their 2013 parting.
8. Khloé Kardashian and Tristan Thompson
In 2022, Khloé Kardashian revealed she rejected a proposal from Tristan Thompson over a year before. Keeping the engagement a secret, Khloé explained her desire for a fundamentally different and more fulfilling relationship and her hesitation to tell her family.
On The Kardashians show she confessed, “And that’s why I said, ‘I’m not comfortable accepting this right now because I’m not excited to tell my family,’ and as hurtful as that probably was for him to hear, it was the truth. I’m not ever gonna accept something or give someone false hope, and I said that to him.”
9. Denzel and Pauletta Washington
Before becoming a Hollywood power couple, Denzel Washington proposed to Pauletta three times. The actor confessed to E! News, “And since it was three times, that means she turned me down twice.” Despite initial rejections, the couple has been happily married since 1983, showcasing that love can overcome early challenges.
10. Katy Perry and John Mayer
After Katy Perry moved on with Orlando Bloom, John Mayer proposed over the phone. Perry, finding a new direction in life, laughed off the proposal, signaling the end of any romantic possibilities with Mayer.
An insider told Hollywood Life, “She pretty much laughed him off the line.”
They also added that “Katy’s so tired of John’s love’ em and leave ’em shtick, and she told him that she can see a real future with Orlando.” Apparently, she was right.
11. Zlatan Ibrahimovic and Helena Seger
Football star Zlatan Ibrahimovic shared how Helena Seger initially rejected his proposal, emphasizing her strength and independence, showing that marriage was not a necessity for their enduring relationship.
For Pirce Morgan he revealed, “She said, ‘I don’t need to be married with you, to be with you.’ She is strong, she is very strong.”
12. Jenna Bush and Henry Hager
In a role reversal, Jenna Bush proposed to Henry Hager, initially receiving a “no.” Despite this, the couple got engaged months later, highlighting the importance of persistence and timing in matters of the heart.
Jenna told Daily Oprah, “After three months of dating—I might’ve had a Christmas cocktail—and we were dancing, and I said, ‘This is it, I know it, let’s just get married, what are we waiting for?’” But apparently, he was not ready. She continued, “He smiled and was like, ‘I’m crazy about you, but you’re young.’”
13. Todd & Julie Chrisley
Can you believe Todd and Julie Chrisley almost didn’t tie the knot? Way back, when Julie was pregnant with Chase, Todd popped the question, but she turned him down. Why? Well, Julie wasn’t keen on marrying him fresh off his divorce, with two kids already in the mix. Savannah spilled the beans on her podcast, Unlocked With Savannah Chrisley, sharing how her mom told Todd, “I’m not marrying you just for you to make the same mistake you made with your first wife.” Todd asked twice and got rejected twice. But check this out – 27 years later, here they are, still going strong. Love’s a crazy ride, huh?
14. Jimmy & Rosalynn Carter
Jimmy Carter and Rosalynn’s love story had a little bump in the road. Back in their late teens, after Rosalynn had been crushing on Jimmy for ages, they finally got together. Jimmy was head over heels and proposed when she visited him at the Naval Academy.
But hold up – she said no! Rosalynn had education on her mind and needed some time. In her own words from “What Makes a Marriage Last,” she said, “I promised my dad, who never finished high school and passed away when I was thirteen, that I’d go to a four-year college.” So, even though she initially turned him down, a few months later, she changed her mind and said yes. Talk about a plot twist!
These celebrity marriage proposal rejections show us that love, even in the glamorous world of Hollywood, is a journey filled with twists and turns. Proposals, though daunting, are integral to this journey, and sometimes, saying “no” opens doors to happier endings elsewhere.
You may also like: This Tourist Proposed in Front of Everyone. She said NO!
