Did You Know UK Teachers Don’t Have to Address Students in Chosen Pronouns?

In a move aimed at clarifying the role of educators in supporting trans students, the Department for Education (DfE) in UK has released new guidance for schools.

This long-anticipated draft legislation has been met with mixed reactions from educators, parents, and advocacy groups.

Key Points of the UK New Trans Guidance for Schools

Parental Involvement

Schools are encouraged to inform parents if their child wishes to change their gender identity at school. However, teachers can withhold this information if they believe the child could be at significant risk.

Cautious Approach

Schools should take a cautious approach to any requests for social transitioning, including changes in name, pronouns, or uniform.

No Compulsion for Pronouns

Teachers and students are not required to use a child’s chosen pronouns if it conflicts with their religious or personal beliefs.

Primary school students (11 years old and younger) should use pronouns corresponding to their biological sex.

Single-Sex Spaces

Schools must maintain single-sex toilets, changing rooms, and sports facilities based on a child’s birth sex. Additionally, schools should include specific guidelines for gender-neutral facilities.

“Schools must not allow a child, aged 11 years or older, to change or wash in front of a child of the opposite sex,” says the guidance.

Uniform and Admissions

Gender-questioning children should adhere to the same uniform standards as other children of their sex. Furthermore, schools must record the biological sex of every pupil in the admissions register.

Single-sex schools retain the authority to refuse admission to students of the opposite biological sex, regardless of their gender identity questions.

Mixed Reactions

Kevin Sexton, head teacher at Chesterfield High School in Liverpool, expressed that the guidance aligns with his current practices. “I’m going to do what I’d basically do now, which is to support the child, to work with the child to actually give them the confidence to tell their parents,” he said.

However, the guidance has not been universally welcomed. Former Prime Minister Liz Truss criticized it for not going far enough to protect children and single-sex spaces. Conversely, advocacy group Sex Matters praised the guidance as a significant step towards removing what they term “trans ideology” from schools.

On the other hand, transgender youth support charity Mermaids condemned the guidance as “unworkable, out of touch, and absurd“. They argue that it could put young people at risk.

Legal Concerns and Public Consultation

The guidance, which will undergo a 12-week public consultation, has also faced legal scrutiny. Government lawyers warned that a presumption against social transitioning might be unlawful. Despite this, the guidance was approved by key government officials. It included Education Secretary Gillian Keegan and Minister for Women and Equalities Kemi Badenoch.

International Perspective

The new guidance applies only to schools in England. Other UK nations have different approaches. For example, Northern Ireland’s guidance advises informing parents with the pupil’s consent, while Scotland’s 2021 guidance includes real-life examples and emphasizes inclusivity.

Voices From the Community

Some educators remain skeptical. An anonymous teacher told BBC, “This new guidance could complicate school life even further and provides little assurance for children who identify as transgender or non-binary.”

Caleb, a 21-year-old who came out as transgender at 16, highlighted the potential dangers of compelling schools to inform unsupportive parents. For BBC he stated, “If schools have a knowledge that a parent is not supportive, they’re not safeguarding that child, they’re sending them home to a completely unsafe environment.”

Moving Forward

As the consultation period begins, various stakeholders, including teachers, parents, and advocacy groups, will have the opportunity to voice their opinions. The outcome of this process will determine whether the new guidance will bring clarity and support to schools or add to the existing complexities surrounding the issue of gender identity in education.

As a parent, how do you feel about this? Share your thoughts and feelings in the comments below.

You may also like: Was This Roman Emperor a Transgender Woman?