The Murder That Took 17 Years to Expose

On December 16, 2000, Mike Williams, a 31-year-old real estate appraiser, vanished during a solo duck hunt on Lake Seminole.

His boat and hunting gear were found, but not his body. Authorities initially suspected a tragic alligator attack, and after 44 days, Mike was declared legally dead. His wife’s formal declaration closed the case, and life insurance payouts followed.

A Suspicious Affair Unfolds

Suspicion arose when Denise Williams, Mike’s widow, quickly began dating—and later married—Brian Winchester, her late husband’s best friend.

Denise and Brian had an affair both years before and after Mike’s disappearance. The rapid shift from grief to romance sparked concern from Mike’s best friend, Kathy Aldredge, and Mike’s mother, Cheryl Williams. The closeness of the four—and the cracked facade—motivated Kathy to quietly investigate the truth.

A Friend in Disguise

Over nearly 17 years, Kathy and Mike’s mother pushed back against assumptions of accident.

Kathy worked covertly, going undercover, recording conversations, and acting as a confidential informant for law enforcement. Her deep conviction—“They stabbed me in the soul,”—spoke to both their betrayal and her drive for justice.

The Body, the Confession, the Verdict

In 2016, a pivotal event unfolded. Brian Winchester was arrested after an attempt to kidnap Denise following their separation.

In exchange for immunity on murder charges, he revealed the location of Mike’s remains—finally retrieved in 2017—and confessed to staging the disappearance on Denise’s instruction. Denise was arrested in 2018, convicted of conspiracy to commit murder, and sentenced to 30 years. Brian was given a 20-year sentence.

Mr. & Mrs. Murder: Truth In Full View

The docuseries Mr. & Mrs. Murder, now streaming, delves deep into the twisted dynamic of friendship, betrayal, and family.

With interviews from Kathy, Cheryl, law enforcement, and archive footage paired with minimalist atmospheric vignettes, the four-part series delivers a gripping portrait of a case long ignored. It’s an emotional testament to persistence in the face of deception.

Justice Belated but Real

For Kathy and Cheryl, justice didn’t come quickly—but their unyielding determination paid off.

The case reminds us that appearances can mask sinister truths, and that sometimes, closure requires defying conventions, shining light into dark corners, and never letting go of the belief that justice can prevail.

You might also want to read: Lorna Raver Dies at 81—Death Uncovered Months Later