Dad Charged With Murder Was Allowed to Go on Family Vacation

Christopher Scholtes, a 49-year-old man from Wisconsin, now finds himself charged with murder after the tragic death of his 2-year-old daughter, identified in court documents as D.S.

The heartbreaking incident unfolded in Lāhainā, Maui, where Scholtes and his family were vacationing. On May 5th, authorities responded to an emergency call and found the toddler unresponsive in a locked, overheated car. She was later pronounced dead at the hospital.

“She Was Sleeping”: A Disturbing Excuse

According to police, Scholtes told his family he was going for a drive to let the baby nap in the car while his wife and their other children went shopping. However, what was initially brushed off as a harmless parenting choice quickly took a chilling turn.

Surveillance footage later showed Scholtes returning to the resort alone, leaving the car parked and locked in the sun for over two hours. He didn’t alert anyone or check on his daughter, despite the scorching heat and mounting risks.

When confronted by his wife later that evening, Scholtes insisted their daughter was still sleeping. But when she rushed to the car, the worst had already happened.

Charges and Contradictions

Scholtes was arrested the next day and charged with second-degree murder. Prosecutors claim he “knowingly” caused his daughter’s death by leaving her inside the car. The medical examiner ruled the cause of death as hyperthermia — a condition caused by excessive body heat, commonly associated with hot car fatalities.

Even more unsettling are the contradictions in Scholtes’ story. At first, he told police the child had been with him for only five minutes, but the timeline from security footage told a different story — one that spanned over two hours.

A Preventable Tragedy

Sadly, this is not an isolated incident. According to Kids and Car Safety, an average of 38 children die every year in the U.S. from being left in hot cars. Even on mild days, temperatures inside a car can rise rapidly, putting young children, whose bodies heat up faster than adults’, at serious risk.

This case serves as a haunting reminder of just how fragile life can be — and how one poor decision can have irreversible consequences. Whether it was carelessness, denial, or something more sinister, the outcome remains the same: a child’s life was cut short far too soon.

The Takeaway

There’s no easy way to process a story like this. It’s heavy, heartbreaking, and frankly, maddening. But what we can do is learn from it. Leaving a child in a car — even for a moment — is never safe.

For now, Scholtes remains in custody on a $1 million bail as the investigation continues. Meanwhile, a family is left shattered, a community stunned, and the public left wondering: how could this have happened?

You might also want to read: Woman Charges Husband $250 for House Chores