Man Jailed After Wife Discovers He Was Married to Other Women

Henry Betsey Jr., 55, appeared before a Georgia court after being convicted on multiple bigamy charges.

It turned out he had legally married two women—one in Virginia in 1995, and another in Georgia in 2003—while also maintaining a long-term relationship with a third woman he’d claimed to be estranged from. The lie fell apart when one marriage ended in divorce, revealing his hidden family structure to authorities.

Deception and Discovery

Betsey’s web of marriages lasted decades before it unraveled. One wife, unaware of the other relationships, discovered inconsistencies while managing legal paperwork.

Her filing for divorce triggered an investigation that exposed Betsey’s multiple legal unions. Prosecutors confirmed he had never legally divorced his first wife, making his later marriages illegal.

What the Court Heard

Court testimony described how Betsey married a second woman in Georgia while still legally bound to his first spouse. Although he claimed he’d separated from his first wife years earlier, no divorce paperwork existed to prove it. A prosecutor stated his deception was intentional—designed to manipulate both families emotionally and financially.

The judge, in sentencing, called the behavior “profoundly calculated and manipulative,” noting Betsey took advantage of goodwill and trust across multiple households.

Consequences Beyond the Courtroom

Betsey was sentenced to up to ten years in prison and ordered to pay restitution to one of the women he had wronged financially. Public records show he maintained separate homes and bank accounts—leaving both wives unaware of each other’s existence, but supporting both households from the same income.

Attorneys said this is one of the more egregious bigamy cases they’ve encountered, both in terms of its duration and emotional damage inflicted.

Community Shock & Emotional Fallout

Neighbors and extended family were stunned to learn of Betsey’s secret life. “He was friendly, helpful, and always polite,” said one neighbor, expressing disbelief at the revelation. Both wives, one of whom had already filed for divorce, released statements through attorneys calling the betrayal devastating—especially to children caught in the crossfire of lies and court battles.

Why This Case Matters

This case isn’t just about marriage fraud—it’s about how identity and trust intersect. In times when serial relationships often bring public discussion, Betsey’s deception echoes deeper questions about personal integrity. It calls attention to how vulnerable people can be when genuine transparency is replaced with calculated concealment.

You might also want to read: Man Stabbed While Protecting Commuters at SF Train Station